← All resources
Money

$600mof mostly super savings went from more than 6,000 Australians into First Guardian, a fund ASIC alleges was run with inadequate checks and unmanaged conflicts. Many were steered there after a friendly offer to check their super. If a stranger offers you one, hang up.

Source: ASIC (30 Oct 2026)

Harrison Spanner · 4 Nov 2026 · 6 min read
Office workers sitting on the steps and paving of Martin Place in Sydney at lunchtime, in sunshine between office towers
Stock photo of office workers in Martin Place, Sydney. Every one of them has a super balance someone wants to move. Photo: Nick-D, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Your super is probably the biggest pile of money you own after your home. That makes it a target. On Friday, ASIC sued the two men who ran First Guardian, alleging millions of members’ dollars were handed over “before contracts were even in place”. Many of the people who lost money never went looking for a new fund. Someone rang them, or answered their click on an ad, and offered to help.

6,000+Australians put money into First Guardian between 2019 and 2025, mostly from super
$57mallegedly paid to companies controlled by the fund’s two bosses
12,000people exposed to First Guardian, Shield and a third frozen scheme, with losses up to $1.2bn

How it works

How a phone call moved people’s super

The pattern ASIC and the complaints authority describe.

1. A “free super check”an online ad or a call out of the blue 2. “Your fund is underperforming”a salesperson collects your details 3. An adviser signs it offoften after little or no real contact 4. Your super is switchedinto a fund heavy in First Guardian or Shield

Sources: Professional Planner, on an AFCA ruling; Moneysmart

ASIC, Moneysmart and the complaints authority all describe “super health check” ads and calls as a common way in. The salespeople were paid well for it. In one case decided by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority, an unlicensed lead generator took 70% of the upfront advice fee and 40% of the ongoing fees. The adviser who signed the advice had no direct contact with the client. One complainant ended up with 60% of their fund in Shield and First Guardian.

What ASIC alleges

These are allegations, and the directors haven’t had their day in court. But the fund froze withdrawals in May 2024 and a court ordered it wound up in April 2025.

The public lobby of the Australian Securities Exchange in Sydney, with share price boards on the walls and people seated at desks
Stock photo of the ASX lobby in Sydney. Most Australians’ super is invested through markets they never see. Photo: Jason7825, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Nobody cold-calls you to make you richer. They call because you’re the product.

The system was supposed to catch this

Every layer had a gatekeeper. The funds sat on super platforms run by licensed trustees, and ASIC has now sued every super trustee that offered either fund. Around $300 million reached First Guardian through Diversa’s funds alone. Some investors have been made whole: Netwealth agreed to fully compensate its First Guardian members, about $100 million, and Macquarie paid $321 million to Shield investors.

What ASIC alleges, by amount

Amounts ASIC alleges, A$ millions

Through funds it controlled270
Assets with little value188
To the bosses’ companies57
Property deals27.9

Categories overlap; they are not a breakdown of the $600m.

Source: ASIC (2026)

Others won’t be so lucky. ABC News reports the liquidator signals that little can be recovered for investors still owed just over $500 million. The last-resort compensation scheme caps payouts at $150,000 and generally covers only people who invested on advice. Its bill is funded by a levy on the rest of the industry, so honest advisers and brokers pay for the dishonest ones, and those costs can flow through to clients in fees.

Aerial view of a housing development in Melbourne, rows of houses next to green paddocks and a racetrack
Stock photo of Melbourne suburbs. The 12,000 people caught up were ordinary savers, not high-flying investors. Photo: LBM1948, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The fix: make your super a closed door

You don’t need to become an investment expert. You need to know where your super is, never let a stranger move it, and know who to call if something looks wrong. All three take minutes, and all the tools are free.

What each fix does

Each one shuts a door the salespeople used.

Just hang upno stranger needs to discussyour super with you Check it yourselfthe ATO’s free tool shows feesand returns for MySuper funds Know what you ownlog in and read yourinvestment options once a year

Sources: Moneysmart; ASIC

When the phone rings

Hang up, block, report

Moneysmart’s red flags: a stranger raising your super, a “free health check” or lost-super offer, a claim your fund is underperforming, a call that moves straight to an adviser, and pressure to decide on the spot. Offering you a financial product in an unsolicited call is generally illegal anyway, under the anti-hawking ban. You can hang up without explaining. If you gave out personal details, call your fund and ask it to block withdrawals. Then put your number on the Do Not Call Register and report the call to ASIC.

Read the red flags →
To compare your fund

The ATO’s YourSuper tool

If you want to know whether your fund is any good, ask the government, not a caller. If you’re in a default (MySuper) option, this shows how it compares. If you’ve been moved into a platform or “choice” product, checking what it invests in matters more. The ATO’s free YourSuper comparison tool ranks MySuper products by fees and returns and shows which have failed APRA’s performance test. You can also find lost super through myGov, for free. Default MySuper products are diversified and didn’t invest in these schemes.

Compare your super →
If you were caught up

Complain to AFCA, free

If you were advised into First Guardian or Shield, lodge a complaint with your adviser first and then with the Australian Financial Complaints Authority. It costs nothing and you don’t need a lawyer. AFCA had received about 1,800 complaints about these funds by early 2026. If the adviser’s firm has collapsed, AFCA’s ruling can lead to the compensation scheme.

Lodge a complaint →

Do this today

For how the biggest money managers already own a slice of your super, read how BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street came to own almost everything.

What to make of it

Thousands of people trusted a friendly voice, and many lost access to their retirement savings. Licensed advisers signed off, licensed trustees put the funds on their menus, and the regulator’s big moves came only after withdrawals were frozen. Some victims have been paid back; many are still waiting. The cheapest protection costs nothing: never let a stranger near your super.

Sources

  1. ASIC (2026): ASIC sues Falcon Capital directors David Anderson and Simon Selimaj alleging First Guardian failures
  2. Professional Planner (2026): Shield, First Guardian lead generators received cut from advice fees
  3. Insurance Business (2026): First Guardian bosses sued as collapse adds to CSLR bill
  4. ABC News (2026): Markets and business live, 30 October
  5. The Guardian (Luca Ittimani) via inkl: Australians lost $1bn through collapsed investment funds
  6. Moneysmart: Protect your super from pushy sales calls
  7. ASIC (2026): ASIC expands list of known entities involved in lead generation
  8. ATO: YourSuper comparison tool

This article is general information, not financial advice. Consider your own circumstances, or speak to a licensed adviser you chose yourself, before acting.