1 in 2or so of 50 retailers the ACCC checked in last year’s Black Friday sales made claims the regulator found concerning. Fake deadlines, hidden exclusions and “up to” discounts almost nothing qualified for.
Source: ACCC (April 2026)

Black Friday lands on 27 November, and the countdown timers are already ticking. Australians were tipped to spend $6.8 billion over last year’s Black Friday to Cyber Monday weekend. When the ACCC reviewed 50 retailers’ sales, about half made claims it found concerning. In September two of them, James Lane and Vuly, paid penalties over sales that ran past their advertised deadlines. The clock on the screen is often not the real deadline, and the “was” price is often not a real price.
How it works
How a fake deal gets you
Each step is designed to stop you comparing prices.
ACCC deputy chair Catriona Lowe says retailers “appear to be increasingly relying on tactics that manipulate consumers by creating a false sense of urgency”. Urgency works because it stops you doing the one thing that beats a fake deal: checking what the price was last month.
What the regulator flagged
- Timers that reset. Vuly’s countdown timers reset to new end dates while the same or bigger discounts carried on, the ACCC said. It paid $39,600 under two infringement notices.
- Extensions planned in advance. James Lane had decided before its Black Friday sale began to run the discount past its advertised end date of 3 December 2025, the ACCC said. It paid $19,800. Neither retailer admitted breaking the law.
- “Sitewide” with exclusions. Some “storewide” sales hid or poorly disclosed the products left out, and some “up to” claims applied to only a few items.
- Prices that were never real. The Federal Court found most of the 74 Emma Sleep products advertised with strikethrough prices had never been sold at that price. Its timer also reset when it hit zero.

Most penalties are small next to the sales
The infringement notices for James Lane and Vuly totalled $59,400. Notices are capped by law at about $20,000 each. Only a court case brings penalties in the millions, and those take years: Emma Sleep’s conduct ran from June 2020 to March 2023, and products sold with its misleading savings claims brought in more than $134 million. The court ordered $15 million in penalties.
Emma Sleep: sales vs penalty
Over the period the court found its ads misleading, June 2020 to March 2023
Sales are revenue, not profit, and not every buyer was swayed by the ads.
Shoppers notice, too. In a 2024 Finder survey of 1,095 people, 52% said they had seen a product’s price go up before a sale, and 11% bought it anyway. In the UK, the consumer group Which? tracked 175 deals from Black Friday 2024 and found 83% were the same price or cheaper at some point in the 6 months before or after.

The fix: check the price, not the clock
You don’t need to skip the sales. You need to know what a thing normally costs before the sale starts, so a fake discount can’t move you.
What each fix does
Each one takes the urgency out of the deal.
Sources: ACCC; ACCC consumer guarantees
Check the price history now
Write down or screenshot the price of anything on your list this week, before the sales start. For Amazon Australia, a free price tracker like camelcamelcamel shows the price over months, so you can see whether a “was” price was ever charged. If the sale price matches last month’s normal price, it isn’t a deal.
Track Amazon prices →Ignore the countdown
Decide the most you’ll pay for each item before the sale, and don’t buy anything that isn’t on your list. If a timer is pushing you, close the tab and come back the next day: the ACCC has found timers that simply reset. Remember that “up to 50% off” can mean only a few items get 50%.
What the ACCC found →Know your refund rights, and report fakes
Under the Australian Consumer Law, a faulty item is covered by the consumer guarantees even if you bought it on sale, whatever a “no refunds on sale items” sign says. Retailers don’t have to refund you for a change of mind. If you spot a timer that resets or a “was” price you never saw, report it to the ACCC.
Your consumer rights →Do this today
- 1. Make a list of what you actually need before 27 November.
- 2. Screenshot today’s prices for each item.
- 3. Set a top price for each, and a total budget.
- 4. On the day, compare the sale price with your screenshot, not with the “was” price.
For why prices keep climbing in the first place, read why prices are rising 4.3% a year.
What to make of it
About half the retailers the regulator looked at made Black Friday claims it found concerning, and it is investigating several of them. Some are real bargains, and a planned purchase at a genuinely lower price is a win. But the countdown timer is a sales tool, not a fact, and a $19,800 infringement notice is small enough that some retailers may treat it as a cost of doing business. The defence is boring and it works: know the normal price before the sale starts.
Sources
- ACCC (2026): ACCC investigating retailers making concerning Black Friday claims
- PPC Land (2026): ACCC fines James Lane and Vuly $59,400 over sales that ran past end dates
- Inside Retail (2026): James Lane and Vuly penalised over misleading Black Friday promotions
- PPC Land (2026): Emma Sleep fined $15m for fake countdown timers and phantom discounts
- Inside Retail (2025): ARA predicts Black Friday bonanza for retailers
- Finder (2024): Sales sham: 1 in 2 shoppers notice product price hikes before sale season
- Which? (2025): Most Black Friday deals the same price or cheaper at other times of the year
- ACCC: Consumer rights and guarantees
This article is general information, not financial or legal advice. Consider your own circumstances before acting.